When sleep has been rocky for a long time, it’s very easy to say “My sleep is broken.” It feels that way: long nights, foggy days, and a brain that seems to ignore how exhausted you are.
But when we zoom in, chronic insomnia is usually a mix of two big things:
- How your nervous system has learned to treat night‑time (as a time to monitor for threats). 12
- How your body clock is lined up (or not) with the rest of your life. 3
Let’s start with the insomnia part, then bring in the circadian rhythm (body‑clock) side and how delayed and advanced phase ‘sleep/wake’ clocks can cleverly masquerade as insomnia.
Insomnia -a nervous system stuck on “high alert”
Clinically, chronic insomnia means ongoing problems with sleep (falling asleep, staying asleep, or waking too early) plus distress or daytime impact, despite having enough opportunity to sleep.2 It’s not just rough patches; it’s when the whole experience of night‑time becomes heavy and loaded 24/7.
Research on insomnia repeatedly points to hyperarousal – a nervous system that’s too switched on – as a core driver. People with chronic insomnia often show:12
- More high‑frequency brain activity during the night.
- Higher baseline heart rate and physiological arousal.
- A strong “threat focus” around sleep and its consequences.
In everyday language, your system quietly learns:
- “Bedtime = something to be careful about/to prepare for.”
- “Being awake at night = dangerous for tomorrow / my health / my performance.”
Over time, the bed can become a cue not for rest, but for effort, monitoring, and self‑judgment. You climb in and your whole system goes, “Here we go again.”
CBT‑I and ACT‑I tend to target exactly this:89
- Reducing how much time you spend awake and distressed in bed.
- Re‑associating bed with sleep and low‑key wakefulness, instead of “battle station.”
- Softening catastrophic beliefs about what a bad night means, and loosening rigid rules that make sleep feel like an exam.
So far, we’ve barely mentioned your body clock. But it’s quietly shaping the when of your sleep, and that’s where circadian issues start to look like insomnia.
Your circadian system: the timing layer
Your circadian rhytm is your internal 24‑hour timing network. It sits in the brain and helps coordinate daily rhythms in sleepiness, alertness, hormone release, body temperature, and more. Light – especially morning light – is its main “setter,” telling your body what time of day it is.4
Sleep at night is shaped by three interacting processes:3
- Sleep Drive: pressure for sleep that builds the longer you’re awake and eases when you sleep.
- Circadian rhythm: your body clock’s prediction of when sleep should happen and when alertness should be promoted.
- It also is driven heavily by what I call the ‘arousal’ system – our fight and flight that creates the upset about not sleeping.
When these line up – high sleep drive at the same time your circadian system is saying “it’s night now” – sleep tends to be deeper and more stable.³ When they’re out of sync with each other, or with your actual obligations (work, school runs, caring responsibilities), you get classic insomnia‑like patterns:
- Exhausted at 9pm but suddenly more awake again at 10–11pm.
- Lying awake for hours at your “sensible” bedtime.
- Waking at 4am like your brain has decided the day needs to start, even though you’re not ready.
From the outside, that’s indistinguishable from insomnia. On the inside, your body clock and your life might simply be arguing about what “bedtime” should be.3
How circadian rhythm problems can mimic insomnia
Circadian rhythm sleep–wake disorders are conditions where the timing of sleep is shifted relative to social norms or personal goals, but when someone is allowed to sleep on their preferred schedule, sleep can be surprisingly OK.3 Two patterns are especially good at masquerading as insomnia:
- Delayed Sleep–Wake Phase Disorder (DSWPD) – the “night owl in an early‑bird world.”
- Advanced Sleep–Wake Phase Disorder (ASWPD) – the “early‑bird who wakes before dawn.”
Both can walk into clinic as:
- “I can’t get to sleep at a normal time.”
- “I keep waking up at 4am and can’t get back to sleep.”
And both often lead to years of extra sleep‑hygiene rules (“no screens after 7pm”, “earlier bedtime”) that don’t shift the pattern and leave you feeling like you’re the problem.8
Let’s look at each.
Delayed phase: the late‑running body clock that looks like sleep‑onset insomnia
Delayed Sleep–Wake Phase Disorder is essentially a late‑shifted body clock. Your natural sleep window is pushed later than what your life expects.56You might not feel truly sleepy until 1–3am (or later), and if you were left alone, you’d naturally wake late morning or lunchtime and often feel and function better.
From the outside, this looks like classic sleep‑onset insomnia:
- You go to bed at 10 or 11pm because that’s “responsible.”
- You lie there for ages, mind racing, body not quite on board.
- Sleep finally arrives in the small hours.
- The alarm drags you out at 6 or 7am and you feel shattered.
The giveaway is what happens when timing is flexible:
- On holidays, when you drift into a 1–2am to 9–10am pattern, your sleep often feels deeper and more continuous.
- When work starts later for a week, you might suddenly feel more like yourself.
Reviews of DSWPD consistently show that this isn’t laziness or “screen addiction.” It’s linked to intrinsic circadian tendencies, light exposure patterns, and sometimes genetics.People with DSWPD may function perfectly well when allowed to live on a delayed schedule.
So if you’ve always been a night owl who only sleeps “normally” when no one needs you up early, it may be more accurate to say, “My clock runs late” than “I can’t sleep.”
Advanced phase: the early clock that feels like stubborn early waking
Advanced Sleep–Wake Phase Disorder is the flip side. Here, your body clock runs early.⁷ You feel genuinely sleepy in the early evening (think 8–9pm), fall asleep quickly, and then wake for the day between about 3–5am, unable to get back to sleep.
From the inside, this can feel like:
- “My sleep is shrinking as I get older.”
- “No matter what I do, I wake at 4am – my brain just switches on.”
From the outside, it looks like sleep‑maintenance insomnia: long stretches of time awake before the alarm goes off.
Again, the clue is what happens when you follow your clock. If you consistently sleep 8:30pm–4:30am, many people with ASWPD get a full, stable block of sleep and feel reasonably OK – it just doesn’t fit with a 9–5 rhythm or social life.⁷ ASWPD is particularly common in older adults and is often dismissed as “normal ageing” rather than recognised as a specific circadian pattern that can be worked with and shifted to make sleep more satisfying.
When circadian misalignment and “true” insomnia team up
Things get really sticky when:
- You have a delayed or advanced circadian pattern and
- Insomnia processes like hyperarousal and conditioned wakefulness build on top.123
A delayed example:
- Your clock is naturally late.56
- You force earlier bedtimes to be good.
- You lie awake, night after night, getting more anxious.
- Your brain learns: “Bedtime is when we fight with sleep.”12
- Now even when you are tired, you get a spike of alertness around bed because the situation feels threatening.12
In that scenario, you don’t just have a timing problem anymore. You have:
- Circadian misalignment (your clock and life don’t match).
- Chronic insomnia (your nervous system has learned to treat night‑time as danger).
The same can happen in advanced phase: early waking may start as a body‑clock issue, but over time it gets wrapped in health fears, dread of the day ahead, and intense pressure to sleep until 6 or 7am. That worry fuels arousal and makes the early‑morning wakefulness feel even more stubborn.¹˒²
This is one reason major insomnia guidelines now emphasise CBT‑I as first‑line treatment for chronic insomnia, not sleep hygiene alone. CBT‑I targets the maintaining processes – hyperarousal, conditioning, unhelpful beliefs, and behaviours that keep insomnia looping – while circadian tools (light and timing) help realign the body clock
Why more and stricter sleep hygiene often makes this worse
If you’ve responded to all this by doubling down on sleep hygiene, you’re in very good company. Many people arrive having tried:
- No caffeine after midday.
- No screens after 7pm.
- Strict bedroom darkness, perfect temperature, endless rituals.
Those habits can support general health, but when insomnia and circadian issues are in play, they often backfire:
- You spend more time in bed awake, which deepens the association between bed and struggle.
- You feel more pressure (“I’ve done everything right, so what’s wrong with me?”).
- You widen the gap between your real body clock and the bedtime you’re forcing.
Guidelines and reviews are pretty consistent: sleep hygiene alone doesn’t work well as a standalone treatment for chronic insomnia, and for circadian rhythm disorders it’s understanding timing and light that really moves the dial.
You haven’t failed sleep hygiene. Sleep hygiene just isn’t designed to do the job you’re asking it to do.
What actually helps: working with the clock and the nervous system
The encouraging part: both circadian misalignment and insomnia are modifiable, even after years.3 5 7
For delayed phase (the late‑running clock), treatment often includes:
- A consistent anchor wake time (yes, even after a rough night) to give your clock a reliable morning cue.
- Morning bright light, ideally outdoors soon after waking, to gently nudge the clock earlier over time.45
- Gradually shifting bedtime earlier in small steps instead of trying to leap from 1am to 10pm overnight
For advanced phase (the too‑early body clock), we usually look at:
- Evening light exposure to push the clock later.
- Reducing very bright light in the very early morning, which can otherwise keep reinforcing that early timing.
- Carefully trialling slightly later bedtimes so the main sleep period edges closer to your desired wake time.
When chronic insomnia is also present – fear of wakefulness, racing thoughts, dread of bedtime – circadian work needs to be paired with CBT‑I / ACT‑I:
- To reduce time awake and distressed in bed.
- To change your relationship with wakefulness (less “emergency,” more “unpleasant but manageable”).
- To loosen rigid rules and perfectionism around sleep.
- To re‑invest in daytime life, so sleep stops being the sole measure of whether you’re okay
It’s not a miracle‑cure, and it does take effort and support, but it’s realistic. You’re not trying to force sleep; you’re helping your body clock line up with your life and teaching your nervous system that night‑time is no longer a crisis.
You’re not broken – but you could be ‘misaligned’
If you see yourself in the late‑night second wind, the brutal early mornings, or the sense of having “tried everything,” here’s the bottom line:
You’re a human whose body clock and life have drifted out of sync, and whose nervous system has gone into over‑protective mode around sleep.
Both of those patterns are understandable. And both are workable.
If this resonates, you’re always welcome to book a free, no‑pressure call and we can talk through what might be going on with your mix of timing, insomnia patterns, and day‑to‑day reality – and what gentle, evidence‑based next steps could look like.
