CBT-I vs ACT-I for Insomnia: Differences, Evidence & How to Choose

CBT-I or ACT-I? A therapist trained in both unpacks how they differ, what the evidence says, who they suit best, and why combining them often works better than either alone.
By Tracy Hannigan, Sleep Therapist
Published: May 13, 2026
Updated: June 25, 2026
6 min read

In This Article You Will Learn

CBT-I (Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Insomnia) is the international gold standard for chronic insomnia, recommended as first-line treatment by NICE, the NHS, and the American College of Physicians
ACT-I (Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for Insomnia) is a newer evidence-based approach that focuses on reducing sleep anxiety and psychological resistance to wakefulness, rather than fighting sleeplessness directly
Research shows both produce comparable improvements in insomnia severity and sleep quality at six months; CBT-I may produce faster initial results, while ACT-I shows stronger anxiety reduction

Table of Contents

If you’ve looked into insomnia treatment, you’ve probably come across the abbreviations CBT-I and ACT-I. Both are evidence-based. Both are recommended over sleeping medication as long-term solutions. And if you’re trying to figure out which one you should pursue, you’re asking the right question.

I trained in both CBT-I and ACT-I, and I integrate techniques from both in my work with clients. Here’s an honest breakdown of what each approach involves, what the research says, and how to think about which fits you better.

What is CBT-I?

CBT-I (Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Insomnia) is a structured, short-term therapy that targets the thoughts and behaviours that maintain chronic insomnia. It typically runs for 4 to 8 sessions and is recommended as the first-line treatment for adult insomnia by NICE, the NHS, and the American College of Physicians.

CBT-I works on two tracks simultaneously.

The behavioural track uses techniques including sleep restriction therapy (removing the time you’re awake in bed from the time you spend in bed (subject to adaptation for low sleep levels and other factors)), stimulus control (retraining your brain to associate bed with sleep rather than wakefulness), and sleep hygiene guidance. This is not a prominent feature – most of my clients have good sleep hygiene.

The cognitive track uses structured exercises to identify and challenge the unhelpful thoughts that maintain hyperarousal — beliefs like “I need 8 hours or I can’t function” or “I’ll never sleep properly again.” These thoughts create the anxiety and vigilance that keep insomnia going long after the original trigger has passed.

Decades of research support CBT-I. Studies consistently show that the vast majority of people with primary insomnia experience meaningful improvement, with gains maintained at follow-up (Morin et al., 2006).

What is ACT-I?

ACT-I (Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for Insomnia) is an evidence-based approach that focuses on reducing the psychological struggle with poor sleep, rather than directly targeting sleep behaviours. It draws on the broader framework of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, applied specifically to insomnia.

Where CBT-I aims to change your thoughts about sleep, ACT-I asks you to change your relationship with those thoughts. The core insight is that fighting wakefulness — the desperate need to sleep, the monitoring, the frustration, the catastrophising — often makes insomnia worse. ACT-I teaches you to let those thoughts and feelings exist without reacting to them in ways that escalate arousal.

The six core components of ACT-I are:

  1. The paradox of control — understanding why trying harder to sleep makes it harder
  2. Acceptance strategies — allowing wakefulness to be present without fighting it
  3. Cognitive defusion — stepping back from sleep-related thoughts rather than believing or eliminating them
  4. Values clarification — reconnecting to what matters in your life regardless of sleep
  5. Mindfulness and present-moment awareness — interrupting the rumination that drives hyperarousal
  6. Behavioural sleep strategies — which overlap with some CBT-I techniques

A 2023 pilot randomised controlled trial published in Nature Scientific Sleep (Shin et al.) found that both ACT-I and CBT-I produced significant improvements in sleep quality, insomnia severity, and how long it takes to fall asleep. Crucially, anxiety was significantly reduced in the ACT-I group but not in the CBT-I group — a meaningful distinction for people whose insomnia is driven primarily by anxiety.

How do CBT-I and ACT-I compare in the research?

Overall, CBT-I and ACT-I produce comparable outcomes for insomnia, but they differ in how they get there and which secondary symptoms they address more effectively.

A 2025 study in the Journal of Sleep Research found that CBT-I was associated with a higher chance of treatment response immediately after treatment, but this advantage disappeared at six-month follow-up — suggesting ACT-I produces gains that consolidate over time.

Research published in Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics found ACT-I “feasible and effective, but not more effective than CBT-I for improvement of insomnia severity and sleep-related quality of life” — with the authors noting further studies are needed on non-inferiority and mechanisms of change.

CBT-IACT-I
Evidence baseExtensive (30+ years of RCTs)Growing (increasing trials since 2015)
Speed of resultsOften faster initial improvementsGains may consolidate more gradually
Long-term outcomesStrongComparable to CBT-I at 6 months
Sleep anxietyAddressed through cognitive restructuringStronger evidence for direct anxiety reduction
Psychological flexibilityLess emphasisCore component
Recommended byNICE, NHS, ACP (first-line)Used alongside CBT-I; growing clinical adoption

CBT-I vs ACT-I: which is right for you?

Neither CBT-I nor ACT-I is universally better. The right approach depends on what’s driving your insomnia and how you relate to sleep anxiety.

CBT-I is a strong starting point if:

  • Your insomnia is primarily behavioural (irregular schedule, too much time in bed, conditioned arousal)
  • You want a structured, step-by-step approach with an extensive evidence base that shows it works – even with chronic pain and perimenopause
  • You’re comfortable with cognitive exercises — identifying and challenging sleep-related thoughts

Consider ACT-I, or an integrated approach, if:

  • Sleep anxiety is a dominant feature — you spend a lot of time dreading bedtime, monitoring your sleep, catastrophising about the consequences. Especially good for perimenopausal insomnia.
  • You’ve tried CBT-I before and found the cognitive restructuring didn’t stick
  • You’ve tried CBT-I before but found strict sleep scheduling impossible
  • You have co-occurring anxiety, depression, or chronic pain that intersects with your sleep
  • You’re exhausted from fighting your thoughts and want a different relationship with them

The most flexible option is a therapist trained in both. In practice, I work with most clients using an integrated model — the sleep-specific behavioural techniques from CBT-I combined with the defusion and acceptance tools from ACT-I. The combination addresses both the patterns that maintain insomnia and the psychological struggle that amplifies it.

Can CBT-I and ACT-I be used together?

Yes. The two approaches are complementary and are frequently integrated in clinical practice. Both target the hyperarousal that maintains chronic insomnia, but through different mechanisms — CBT-I through restructuring and behaviour change, ACT-I through acceptance and values-based action.

Research published in Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics on ACT combined with bedtime restriction (a core CBT-I technique) suggests the combination is feasible and effective. Many experienced insomnia therapists draw on both frameworks, adapting the balance to the individual. That is absolutely how I work with my clients.

Frequently Asked Questions About CBTI vs ACTI For Insomnia

References

  1. Shin, J. W., Kim, S., Shin, Y. J., Park, B., & Park, S. (2023). Comparison of acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) and cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) for chronic insomnia: A pilot randomized controlled trial. Nature Scientific Sleep, 15, 523--531.
  2. Morin, C. M., et al. (2006). Psychological and behavioral treatment of insomnia. Sleep, 29(11), 1398--1414.
  3. American College of Physicians. (2016). Cognitive behavioral therapy as first-line treatment for chronic insomnia. Annals of Internal Medicine, 165(2), 125--133.
  4. NICE (2024). Menopause: diagnosis and management (NG23, updated November 2024). National Institute for Health and Care Excellence.

The information contained above is provided for information purposes only. The contents of this page are not intended to amount to advice and you should not rely on any of the contents of this page. Professional advice should be obtained before taking or refraining from taking any action as a result of the contents of this page. Tracy Hannigan disclaims all liability and responsibility arising from any reliance placed on any of the contents of this page.

Tracy, a red-haired sleep therapist, smiles warmly

I’m Tracy Hannigan, an insomnia therapist specialising in CBT‑I, ACTI and other evidence based approaches. Check out my services.