FAQ: Myth-Busting
22 evidence-based questions and answers about myth-busting — written by Tracy Hannigan, qualified sleep therapist.
Last updated: June 2026
Browse all FAQ topics →
No — and this myth causes a surprising amount of suffering. Sleep need is genetically determined and highly individual, ranging from around six hours to ten hours in healthy adults. The eight-hour figure is a population average, not a prescription.
If you're waking up without an alarm feeling reasonably refreshed, functioning well through the day, and not constantly fighting fatigue, you are getting enough sleep for you — whatever that number is. Chasing eight hours when you naturally need seven (or six and a half) is the equivalent of stretching pizza dough across a larger stone than it can cover — and we know how that ends.
Yes — completely normal. All sleepers cycle through stages of sleep, with natural periods of lighter sleep that can involve brief awakenings, typically every 90 minutes or so. Most of these awakenings are so brief they are never remembered.
Waking two or three times in a night is within the range of completely normal sleep, particularly for adults over 40. What matters is whether you can return to sleep easily after waking. The problem in insomnia is not the waking itself — it's the arousal response that makes getting back to sleep difficult.
The fear of permanent brain damage is one of the most distressing aspects of insomnia, often fuelled by scary headlines about dementia. The reality: the cognitive difficulties you experience (foggy thinking, word-finding difficulties, poor concentration) are real but represent the functional effects of fragmented sleep, not permanent structural damage.
The research on insomnia and dementia risk is at an early and correlational stage. More importantly, the fear that your brain is being damaged is itself a major arousal trigger — meaning it is actively contributing to the insomnia. It is one of the most important fears to gently examine and challenge.
This is one of the most common fears, and it deserves a careful answer. Chronic insomnia is genuinely unpleasant and affects quality of life, mood, and cognitive function — and those things matter.
However, the alarming health headlines about sleep and heart disease, dementia, and cancer are largely drawn from research on sleep apnoea and severe sleep deprivation, not on insomnia. People with insomnia tend to be physiologically hyperaroused — their systems are running hot, not shutting down.
The fear of long-term health consequences is real and understandable, but that fear itself raises arousal and perpetuates the insomnia. Getting effective treatment is the best health investment you can make.
The fear of permanent brain damage is one of the most distressing aspects of insomnia, often fuelled by scary headlines about dementia.
The reality: the cognitive difficulties you experience (foggy thinking, word-finding difficulties, poor concentration) are real but represent the functional effects of fragmented sleep, not permanent structural damage. The research on insomnia and dementia risk is at an early and correlational stage.
More importantly, the fear that your brain is being damaged is itself a major arousal trigger — meaning it is actively contributing to the insomnia. It is one of the most important fears to gently examine and challenge.
There is some evidence that disrupted sleep can modestly raise blood pressure over time, but it is important to distinguish between insomnia and sleep apnoea here — most of the strong cardiovascular data relates to sleep apnoea, not to insomnia per se.
If you have concerns about blood pressure, please do see your GP, but try not to let fear of cardiovascular consequences feed your sleep anxiety further — because that fear itself raises arousal and makes sleep harder.
Getting effective treatment for your insomnia is the most positive step you can take.
Chronic sleep deprivation does have real health implications — on mood, cognitive function, immune health, and metabolic regulation — and it is right to take it seriously.
However, there is an important distinction to make: the most serious health outcomes associated with poor sleep in the research literature relate primarily to sleep apnoea, not to insomnia. People with insomnia who are getting fragmented but present sleep are in a different category from those with untreated sleep apnoea.
And crucially, the fear of health consequences from insomnia raises arousal and perpetuates the insomnia itself — so while it is worth addressing, catastrophising doesn't help.
No — and this might be the most liberating thing you read today. Sleep cannot be forced. It is a passive process that happens in the absence of effort, not because of it.
Every time you "try harder" to sleep, you activate the arousal system that prevents it. Willpower, determination, and effort — the qualities that serve you brilliantly in almost every other area of life — are actively counterproductive when it comes to sleep. The skill of insomnia recovery is not trying harder; it is learning to take your hands off the situation entirely.
A wind-down period before bed can be genuinely helpful — and I'd encourage it — but a rigid, timed "power down hour" protocol that you follow anxiously is a different thing entirely.
The value of winding down is in the gradual lowering of arousal: moving away from stimulating, activating content and activities toward quieter, lower-key ones. If your wind-down is relaxed and enjoyable, it's helpful. If it's a source of stress (did I start it on time? am I doing the right things in the right order?), it's feeding the problem. Flexibility is the key.
Not necessarily. While a dark room reduces the chance of external light waking you, you absolutely do not need total blackout conditions to sleep. Plenty of excellent sleepers sleep in rooms with some ambient light, or share beds with partners who read until late.
The problem with obsessive darkness (duct-taping blinds, wearing eye masks, eliminating every photon) is not the darkness itself — it's the fear behind it. If you believe you cannot sleep without perfect darkness, and your heart rate rises when a little light creeps in, that fear is what's keeping you awake, not the light.
Not always — and this is one of the more counterintuitive findings in the sleep field. Meditation can be excellent for reducing arousal, but only when the intention behind it is not to force sleep.
When you meditate in order to make yourself sleep, you are signalling to your arousal system that not sleeping is a threat requiring active intervention — which keeps the threat-detection system engaged and undermines the very state you are trying to reach. This is the same mechanism that makes pillow sprays, bedtime yoga, and elaborate wind-down rituals lose their effectiveness over time when done with sleep as the goal. Meditation pursued because you find it genuinely settling — and practised during the day as much as at night — is a different proposition entirely. The research on mindfulness-based therapies for insomnia (Ong et al., Sleep, 2014) consistently uses this stance: meditation as an attitude toward thoughts and sensations, not as a sleep technique.
The practice itself is neutral. The intention behind it determines whether it helps you let go — or quietly tells your nervous system that sleep is something to be wrestled with.
Mindfulness and meditation can be excellent tools for reducing arousal and supporting sleep — but with one important caveat. If you meditate in order to make yourself sleep, you are sending your arousal system the message that not sleeping is a threat that requires active intervention.
The intent matters. Meditating because you find it genuinely settling and enjoyable — and doing it during the day as well as in the evening — is very different from meditating as a desperate last resort to force sleep.
The practice itself is neutral; the intention behind it determines whether it helps or maintains the problem.
Not necessarily, and this surprises many people. Exhaustion and sleepiness are not the same thing. You can be severely fatigued while the arousal system is so activated that sleep is still not possible.
People with insomnia experience this every night — exhausted to the core, but unable to sleep. Genuine sleep pressure (sleep drive, the balloon) does accumulate over waking hours and eventually becomes powerful enough to overcome even significant arousal — but this is a slow-building biological process, not something that switches on because you feel tired enough.
True short sleepers — people with a genetic variant that allows them to feel fully rested on five or six hours — do exist, but they are rare (estimated at around 3% of the population). What's much more common is people who believe they are short sleepers because they have adapted to chronic sleep deprivation over years.
The adaptation to insufficient sleep involves reduced sensitivity to sleepiness (you stop noticing how bad you feel), not actual reduced need. If you're a true short sleeper, you feel genuinely well-functioning and energetic on six hours without any effort. If you're a chronic under-sleeper, you'll see the consequences in mood, concentration, and physical health over time.
Largely, yes — but this is not a dismissal. The placebo effect is real, powerful, and physiologically measurable, particularly in conditions driven by the arousal system. When you believe a supplement will help you sleep, your arousal comes down, and sleep becomes easier.
But the mechanism is your own nervous system relaxing, not the supplement itself. This matters because placebo effects are unstable — they fade as the novelty wears off, and then people conclude the supplement "stopped working" and look for the next thing, perpetuating the cycle and eroding confidence in their own natural ability to sleep.
No. The evidence that blue light from screens significantly disrupts sleep in real-world conditions is considerably weaker than the marketing for blue light glasses implies, and even if screen light were a major factor, glasses would not address the mechanisms sustaining chronic insomnia.
The blue-light hypothesis holds that short-wavelength light suppresses melatonin and delays circadian timing; this effect exists in controlled laboratory conditions, but in real-world studies the impact of typical evening screen use is modest, and even in the lab the difference in sleep onset between groups was a matter of minutes. A systematic review by Singh et al. (American Journal of Ophthalmology, 2021) found no high-quality evidence that blue-light-filtering lenses improve sleep quality. More importantly, chronic insomnia is maintained primarily by conditioned arousal — the learned association between bed and wakefulness — and by the anxiety that accompanies persistent sleep difficulty. Blue light glasses address neither. The content viewed before bed (news, social media, sleep forums) is substantially more likely to affect sleep than the wavelength of light.
Blue light glasses are not a treatment for insomnia. CBT-I is. Your phone is not making you arouse-prone — it's what you are doing on it.
In the short term, your body does adapt to sleep restriction in that you stop noticing how impaired you feel — but this is not the same as needing less sleep. The underlying impairments (to reaction time, emotional regulation, immune function, metabolic health) continue even when you feel subjectively "fine" on less sleep.
This adaptation is one of the reasons chronic sleep deprivation is insidious — people often don't realise how cognitively and physically affected they are because they've adapted to their baseline. Genuine sleep need reduction would require a genetic change, not adaptation through practice.
Older adults do experience changes in sleep architecture — they spend less time in deep slow-wave sleep and more time in lighter sleep stages, and they may find they wake earlier and feel sleepy earlier (advancing circadian rhythm). However, the total sleep need does not dramatically decrease with age.
What changes is the pattern and structure of sleep, not the requirement. Many older adults do sleep fewer hours but this often reflects their changed sleep architecture and earlier rising rather than a genuinely reduced need. If an older adult is waking much earlier and feels unrested, this warrants exploration rather than acceptance as "just what happens with age."
Normal sleep for an adult involves:
- Falling asleep within around 20–30 minutes.
- Waking two or three times during the night (most of which are forgotten).
- Dreaming during REM cycles (which occur predominantly in the second half of the night).
- Feeling reasonably refreshed on waking.
Sleep naturally cycles through light, deep, and REM stages approximately every 90 minutes. There is no requirement to sleep in one unbroken eight-hour block — this cultural expectation is partly historical (pre-industrial sleep was often biphasic). Normal sleep is also highly variable from night to night, even in excellent sleepers.
Absolutely — and it is one of the defining experiences of insomnia. "Wired but tired" is the feeling of physical exhaustion combined with a brain that simply will not switch off.
It is the perfect encapsulation of what hyperarousal does: the body is exhausted, sleep drive is high, but the nervous system is still running the threat-detection programme and preventing sleep from happening. It is not a sign of something uniquely wrong with you — it is the physiological signature of a hyperactivated arousal system doing its job very, very efficiently.
The "no screens" advice is correct in principle (screens can be stimulating and delay sleep), but it often doesn't engage with the reality that many people use screens for genuinely settling activities (watching familiar comfort shows, listening to podcasts, reading on a tablet).
The actual issue is what you're watching or reading and how it affects your emotional and cognitive arousal, not the device per se. If a particular screen activity is calming and familiar and you sleep fine afterwards, the device is not your problem. The most important intervention is not the device but the content — specifically, reducing sleep-monitoring, anxiety-provoking, or highly activating content before bed.
Poor sleep can influence appetite-regulating hormones in ways that may modestly increase cravings — but the relationship is complex, and the headlines tend to overstate it.
Spiegel et al. (Annals of Internal Medicine, 2004) demonstrated that two nights of restricted sleep (4 hours per night) reduced leptin by 18% and raised ghrelin by 28% in healthy young men, alongside increased hunger and appetite for high-carbohydrate foods. However, this study used severe acute restriction in a laboratory setting, which is not the same as chronic insomnia in daily life. The more practically relevant pathway for most insomnia sufferers is behavioural: fatigue reduces motivation for exercise, makes good food decisions harder, and tends to shift choices toward quick-energy foods. Improving sleep generally has a positive downstream effect on these health behaviours rather than producing direct hormonal weight loss.
Try not to add "I'm gaining weight because of my insomnia" to the worry pile. The research is modest, the mechanism is mostly behavioural, and addressing sleep tends to make eating and movement easier as a side effect.